Leaving performance-enhancing drugs (PEDs) out of the equation for a moment, and looking at the raw numbers alone, here’s a list of players from the 2013 BBWAA ballot sorted by career WAR. (I also looked at the trendy JAWS and didn’t like it.)

Player WAR Summary
Barry Bonds 158 762 HR, .444 OBP, 7x MVP
Roger Clemens 134 354-184, 143 ERA+, 7x CYA
Jeff Bagwell 77 MVP, RoY, 4x A-S, GG
Curt Schilling 76 216-146, 127 ERA+, 3x CY #2
Larry Walker 70 MVP, 7x GG, 3x BA #1
Alan Trammell 67 6xA-S, 4x GG
Rafael Palmeiro 66 569 HR, 4x A-S, 3x GG
Tim Raines 66 808 SB, 7x A-S
Kenny Lofton 65 6x A-S, 4 GG, ’94 WAR #1
Edgar Martinez 64 7x A-S, 2x BA #1
Craig Biggio 62 3060 H, RS #15, HBP #2
Mark McGwire 59 583 HR,12x A-S, GG
Mike Piazza 56 427 HR #1 @ C, 10 xSS, 12x A-S
Sammy Sosa 55 ’98 MVP, 7x A-S, 609 HR-8th
David Wells 49 239-157, pWAR #81
Fred McGriff 48 5x A-S, 2x HR #1
Bernie Williams 46 ’98 BA #1,5x A-S, 4x GG
Dale Murphy 43 2x MVP, 7x A-S, 5x GG
Steve Finley 40 304 HR, 320 SB, 5x GG
Julio Franco 40 5xSS, played to age 62
Don Mattingly 40 MVP, 6xA-S, 9x GG
Jack Morris 39 5x A-S, 2xW #1
Reggie Sanders 37 305 HR, 304 SB
Jeff Cirillo 32 ’96-’01 WAR @ 3B #2
Shawn Green 31 328 HR, ’99AL-TB #1
Lee Smith 28 478 SV, 7x A-S
Woody Williams 28 132-116, 103 ERA+, A-S
Rondell White 26 108 OPS+, +52 rFld, 2x A-S
Ryan Klesko 25 278 HR, 128 OPS+
Aaron Sele 18 148-112, 2x A-S
Roberto Hernandez 17 326SV, >> Mesa
Royce Clayton 16 2x dWAR #1, 1904H
Jeff Conine 16 Mr. Marlin, 1982 H, 2xA-S
Mike Stanton 13 68-63, 84 SV, 112 ERA+, A-S
Sandy Alomar 12 RoY, 6x A-S, GG
Jose Mesa 10 321 SV, 100 ERA+, 2x A-S
Todd Walker 8 .289 BA, ’02 F%/PO @ 2B #1

Source: Baseball-Reference / 2013 HOF candidates

Now let’s talk PEDs. I’ve thought long and hard about it, and here’s where I land: Players who may have used PEDs should be allowed into the Hall of Fame. MLB is the one that should be blamed.

Cheating Isn’t New, But MLB’s Response Was

Cheating has always been a part of baseball: spitballs, greenies, corked bats, sign stealing, pine tar, scuffed balls, you name it. PEDs were just the latest method. The Hall already houses players from eras soaked in amphetamines and other quiet edges. That doesn’t make steroids fine. It does make the idea that PED users are a unique moral stain feel selective.

It’s MLB’s responsibility to recognize, manage, and punish cheaters. It’s MLB’s responsibility to a) monitor players to ensure fair play, b) enforce clear rules and bans, and c) create consequences for violations. MLB busted Joe Jackson and Pete Rose for offenses so malicious that they were banned from the game and Hall of Fame forever. OK, that kind of cheating is bad. Got it.

But when it comes to PEDs? The timeline matters more than the lecture.

Steroids were illegal under federal law by the early 1990s, and in 1991 Commissioner Fay Vincent issued a memo that expressly put them on baseball’s prohibited list. On paper, the ban existed. In practice, MLB did almost nothing with it for more than a decade. There was no meaningful collectively bargained testing program for major leaguers. There were almost no real consequences. Players, writers, and even people inside the game later said they barely knew the memo existed.

Anonymous survey testing finally arrived in 2003. Punitive testing followed in 2004. The first major leaguer suspended under the new steroid policy was Alex Sanchez of Tampa Bay, on April 3, 2005 — a 10-day slap. Real teeth, including 50-game suspensions for a first offense, came later.

So for most of the home-run explosion everyone wants to moralize about now, steroids were banned in theory and ignored in practice. Using in 1998 was against policy in a world with almost no enforcement. Using in 2010 was defying a bargained, public, actively enforced rulebook. Those are not the same institutional story. They are both cheating. Only one of them happened under a league that had decided to act like it cared.

MLB never busted Bonds or Clemens or McGwire or Bagwell in any way that matched the scale of the alleged offense. And when a big name, Rafael Palmeiro, finally got popped, his wrist-slap included a 10-day suspension. That’s it. He finished the season with the Orioles like nothing happened.

Easier for MLB to turn a blind eye to offensive explosions that were generating buzz, driving ratings, and bringing fans to the ballpark. After the 1994–95 strike, baseball needed a comeback story. The 1998 McGwire–Sosa chase gave it one. MLB sold that spectacle, celebrated those nights, and only got serious about PEDs when Congress and public pressure made looking away expensive. The redemption arc was built on the long ball. The cleanup crew was supposed to be writers and fans, years later.

We are now post-career for most of these guys, and their windows for Hall of Fame eligibility opened, closed, and in some cases got shoved into the Era Committees. It is during that stretch that fans and writers were expected to urgently negotiate this moral dilemma. Should we let them in? Is PED use cheating? Is it worse than other forms of cheating? What proof is there? Can test results be trusted?

Clouding the issue are players who have admitted using PEDs after their careers. Is that noble? Does an admission pave the way to the Hall of Fame? My take is that post-career admissions are cowardly. Not as cowardly as those who never admit it at all, but still cowardly. You’ve played your career, cashed your checks, cheated your fans. True integrity would have meant coming clean during your career, when there was something to lose.

Let’s say a criminal confesses his crimes after committing them but before he’s caught. Is that noble? No. He’ll be taken into custody, tried in court, and punished to the fullest extent of the law.

What is MLB doing with admitted PED users? Giving them jobs as batting coaches, TV commentators, and respected ambassadors of the game. MLB has altogether stayed out of the discussion of whether or not these players should be enshrined in the Hall of Fame. Easier to let fans and writers clean up the mess.

And then there’s Bud Selig.

Selig was commissioner through almost the entire Steroid Era, from 1992 to 2015. He presided over the home-run boom, the McGwire–Sosa chase, Bonds’s record seasons, and MLB’s long refusal to build a real testing regime until outside pressure forced the issue. In 2017, the Hall of Fame inducted him.

Barry Bonds and Roger Clemens are still outside.

If Cooperstown can honor the commissioner who oversaw baseball’s failure to police PEDs, excluding the players who defined that era is not principle. It’s theater. The Hall already made its institutional choice when it put Selig in a plaque. Pretending Bonds and Clemens are uniquely unfit after that is incoherent.

What Now?

My take is that the players cheated, but MLB cheated harder by refusing to take a moral stance on PED use and instead turning a blind eye for profit. So let them in. Bonds, Clemens, McGwire, A-Rod, even Palmeiro. Let them in, not because they were clean, but because they were historic. They shaped the game, drove ratings, filled stadiums, and defined an era — an era that MLB willfully allowed to happen.

The Hall of Fame is already filled with problematic figures. Let’s stop pretending it’s a cathedral of virtue. It’s a museum, one that has taken an odd stance on suspected PED users. At least one Barry Bonds home run ball lives there, but not the man himself. So what are we talking about, here? These players, and their PED use, are part of baseball’s story. If you want context on a plaque or in an exhibit, fine. Exile is not context. Exile is pretending the story didn’t happen the way it happened.

As fans, let’s sit back and enjoy watching the best players from our generation, PEDs and all, go into the Hall of Fame without being burdened by the responsibility of moral judgment and punishment. It’s not our job to protect the Hall. It’s MLB’s job to protect the game, and it didn’t. It’s MLB, not the players, that should be judged and punished for dropping the ball.

Let ’em in, and then let’s all agree that the Hall of Fame doesn’t mean anything anymore, thanks to MLB. Or at least admit what it does mean: greatness, history, and whatever morality the people running baseball were willing to enforce at the time. In the Steroid Era, that morality was for sale.

Thoughts on Specific Players

Jeff Bagwell
His stance was unusual, but there was nothing special about it that helped him hit home runs. Note how few he hit in the minors and early career with essentially the same stance. Given his minor league stats, the fact that he hit substantially more home runs AFTER the traditional power peak of age 27–28, and his notable change in body appearance, I’d bet that Bagwell did steroids. Regardless, for reasons stated above, I think he belongs in the HOF. The writers eventually agreed. He’s in.

Barry Bonds
An obvious user. No player in history had as great a resurgence as he did after age 34. It was unprecedented and unnatural.

None of the other players who have used steroids were as good as Bonds. Without steroids, McGwire may have been an above average hitter, Sosa likely would have been below average (at least their minor league numbers seem to suggest this).

And all those MVP awards? How can he be morally sound enough to be voted the league’s best player seven times but be prohibited from being recognized as one of the best players in baseball history?

Also: Bonds was already a Hall of Famer before the late explosion. The PEDs years make the case grotesque. They do not create the case from nothing. He played most of that late peak in the gap between paper bans and real testing, and MLB never suspended him for a positive test. Then the Hall inducted the commissioner of that same era. Nice.

Jose Canseco
You may call him an opportunist, but I call him a breath of fresh air. He was the first guy to speak openly about it, and you can argue that his 2005 book blew the cover off the Steroid Era. I’m surprised no serious attempts on his life have been made.

Roger Clemens
With pitchers, things get a bit murky. There are lots of opinions about how PEDs help pitchers, but here’s mine: Steroids make pitchers stronger, but they also make them more susceptible to injury. Muscles simply become too strong for the tendons that attach them to bones. Look at how many young, muscle-bound pitchers blow their arms out these days.

Perhaps the careful use of HGH prolongs a pitcher’s career by allowing him to recover and heal more quickly, and this may have been how Clemens and other pitchers unnaturally extended their careers.

Either way, Clemens was elite long before the PED cloud. Same institutional story as Bonds: greatness established early, later years contested, MLB never imposed a public PED suspension that matched the moral exile voters later invented for him, and Selig got the plaque anyway.

Mark McGwire
Proof that MLB just doesn’t care. After admitting to steroid use throughout his career in 2010, he became hitting coach for the St. Louis Cardinals. Disgusting. Also, again: the league that celebrated his 1998 chase later asked everyone to treat him like baseball poison.

David Ortiz
OK, there’s no publicly failed drug test or confession. But look at his career progression. Decent player with the Twins (0.9 WAR/162 G), tenuously holding onto a job until age 27, and then he blew up with the Red Sox (4.4 WAR/162 G) to become one of the game’s greatest hitters from age 27 to 40, retiring while still one of the best bats in baseball. Has anyone had a career shaped like that before?

He’s in the Hall now, but why him and not other accused players?

Manny Ramirez
Got busted. Three times. Idiot. This is closer to the post-enforcement story: clear rules, real testing, public suspensions. But this is not evidence to prove MLB was serious all along.

Alex Rodriguez
Might have been one of the best players in history without steroids. Now he’s just another asterisk who, by the way, is a respected commentator and frequent voice on how the game should be played. Convenient how MLB keeps the useful version of him (TV voice, opinions, content) and writers handle the shame.

Categories: Baseball

0 Comments

Leave a Reply

Avatar placeholder

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *