Leaving performance-enhancing drugs (PEDs) out of the equation for a moment, and looking at the raw numbers alone, here’s a list of players from the 2013 BBWAA ballot sorted by career WAR. (I also looked at the trendy JAWS and didn’t like it.)
| Player |
WAR |
Summary |
| Barry Bonds |
158 |
762 HR, .444 OBP, 7x MVP |
| Roger Clemens |
134 |
354-184, 143 ERA+, 7x CYA |
| Jeff Bagwell |
77 |
MVP, RoY, 4x A-S, GG |
| Curt Schilling |
76 |
216-146, 127 ERA+, 3x CY #2 |
| Larry Walker |
70 |
MVP, 7x GG, 3x BA #1 |
| Alan Trammell |
67 |
6xA-S, 4x GG |
| Rafael Palmeiro |
66 |
569 HR, 4x A-S, 3x GG |
| Tim Raines |
66 |
808 SB, 7x A-S |
| Kenny Lofton |
65 |
6x A-S, 4 GG, ’94 WAR #1 |
| Edgar Martinez |
64 |
7x A-S, 2x BA #1 |
| Craig Biggio |
62 |
3060 H, RS #15, HBP #2 |
| Mark McGwire |
59 |
583 HR,12x A-S, GG |
| Mike Piazza |
56 |
427 HR #1 @ C, 10 xSS, 12x A-S |
| Sammy Sosa |
55 |
’98 MVP, 7x A-S, 609 HR-8th |
| David Wells |
49 |
239-157, pWAR #81 |
| Fred McGriff |
48 |
5x A-S, 2x HR #1 |
| Bernie Williams |
46 |
’98 BA #1,5x A-S, 4x GG |
| Dale Murphy |
43 |
2x MVP, 7x A-S, 5x GG |
| Steve Finley |
40 |
304 HR, 320 SB, 5x GG |
| Julio Franco |
40 |
5xSS, played to age 62 |
| Don Mattingly |
40 |
MVP, 6xA-S, 9x GG |
| Jack Morris |
39 |
5x A-S, 2xW #1 |
| Reggie Sanders |
37 |
305 HR, 304 SB |
| Jeff Cirillo |
32 |
’96-’01 WAR @ 3B #2 |
| Shawn Green |
31 |
328 HR, ’99AL-TB #1 |
| Lee Smith |
28 |
478 SV, 7x A-S |
| Woody Williams |
28 |
132-116, 103 ERA+, A-S |
| Rondell White |
26 |
108 OPS+, +52 rFld, 2x A-S |
| Ryan Klesko |
25 |
278 HR, 128 OPS+ |
| Aaron Sele |
18 |
148-112, 2x A-S |
| Roberto Hernandez |
17 |
326SV, >> Mesa |
| Royce Clayton |
16 |
2x dWAR #1, 1904H |
| Jeff Conine |
16 |
Mr. Marlin, 1982 H, 2xA-S |
| Mike Stanton |
13 |
68-63, 84 SV, 112 ERA+, A-S |
| Sandy Alomar |
12 |
RoY, 6x A-S, GG |
| Jose Mesa |
10 |
321 SV, 100 ERA+, 2x A-S |
| Todd Walker |
8 |
.289 BA, ’02 F%/PO @ 2B #1 |
Source: Baseball-Reference / 2013 HOF candidates
Now let’s talk PEDs. I’ve thought long and hard about it, and here’s where I land: Players who may have used PEDs should be allowed into the Hall of Fame. MLB is the one that should be blamed.
(more…)